Italian Beef Sandwich

My first real Chicago winter hit me like a freight train, and somewhere between shivering walks to the EL and watching my breath cloud in the air, a coworker mentioned I had to try an Italian beef sandwich. She dragged me to this tiny stand where they literally dipped the entire bun into beef juice before wrapping it up in paper, and I stood there confused until I took that first bite. Something about that combination of tender beef, spicy crunch, and bread soaked through with savory jus just clicked in my brain. Now every time I smell slow-cooked beef and Italian herbs, I am back on a freezing street corner with steam rising off my sandwich.

Last winter I made these for a Super Bowl party, and my brother who claims to hate sandwiches went back for thirds. The house smelled incredible all day, and by game time everyone was hovering around the kitchen island waiting for their turn. Something magical happens when people stand around dipping sandwiches together, getting juices on their chins, debating whether mild or hot giardiniera is better. Now it is not just a recipe, it is the thing friends actually ask for by name.

Ingredients

• 3 lbs beef chuck roast: Chuck has the perfect marbling for slow cooking, breaking down into melt in your mouth shreds while staying juicy and flavorful
• 1 tbsp olive oil: Helps achieve that beautiful crust when searing, creating depth of flavor that simmers through the entire cooking process
• 1 tsp kosher salt and 1/2 tsp black pepper: Simple seasoning that amplifies the beefs natural flavor without competing with the herbs
• 2 cups beef broth plus 1 cup water: The broth provides rich beef flavor while the water keeps the sodium in check and creates enough liquid for proper braising
• 1 tbsp Worcestershire sauce: Adds that umami punch and subtle tang that makes the jus taste like it has been simmering all day at a sandwich shop
• 1 tbsp dried Italian seasoning: The classic herb blend that gives this sandwich its signature aromatic profile and familiar comforting taste
• 1 tsp each garlic powder and onion powder: Consistent seasoning that disperses evenly through the cooking liquid, unlike fresh garlic which can burn or become bitter
• 1/2 tsp crushed red pepper flakes: Optional heat that builds slowly in the background, warming you up without overwhelming the other flavors
• 6 sturdy Italian rolls: You need rolls that can handle being soaked in jus without falling apart, something with a crusty exterior and soft interior
• 1 1/2 cups hot giardiniera: Chicago style pickled vegetables that bring crunch, heat, and vinegar brightness to cut through the rich beef

Instructions

Prep the beef for its long bath:

Pat that chuck roast completely dry with paper towels until no moisture remains on the surface, then sprinkle it all over with kosher salt and black pepper like you are tucking it in for a nap

Sear for flavor foundation:

Heat your olive oil in a large Dutch oven over medium high heat until it shimmers, then brown the beef on every single side until you have a gorgeous dark crust, about 3 to 4 minutes per side

Build the braising liquid:

Pour in the beef broth, water, Worcestershire sauce, Italian seasoning, garlic powder, onion powder, red pepper flakes if you want some background heat, and tuck in that bay leaf like a little flavor treasure

Let it go low and slow:

Bring everything to a gentle bubble, cover it tightly, then either slide it into a 325 degree oven for 4 hours or set your slow cooker to low for 8 hours, flipping the beef halfway through

Rest and shred:

Move that beautifully tender beef to a cutting board and let it rest for 10 minutes while you skim any excess fat floating on top of the cooking liquid

Return to the juices:

Use two forks to pull the beef apart into shreds, tossing out any big pieces of fat, then drop all that shredded meat back into the pot so it can drink up all those juices

Ready your rolls:

Split those Italian rolls open and give them a quick toast if you want, which creates a nice barrier against the juicy meat while still letting everything soak through

Build the masterpiece:

Pile hot shredded beef onto each roll, spooning some of that precious au jus over the meat, then crown it with a generous handful of giardiniera and those roasted peppers if you are feeling fancy

Pin it

My dad grew up outside Chicago and when he finally tried my version, he got quiet for a minute and said this actually tastes like the ones from the neighborhood stand. That was better than any compliment I could have asked for. It makes me think about how food connects us to places and memories, how a sandwich can transport you across decades and miles to a cold day when something warm and filling felt like the best thing in the world.

Making It Your Own

The beauty of this recipe is how it adapts to whatever you are craving or have on hand. Sometimes I throw in sliced bell peppers with the braising liquid so they soften down into sweet ribbons woven through the beef. Other times I add a splash of red wine for deeper complexity or a spoonful of tomato paste for richness.

The Bread Dilemma

Finding the right roll matters more than I initially realized. Too soft and it disintegrates into a sad mess, too crusty and you lose that perfect bread to meat ratio. I look for rolls with some structure but still tender inside, sometimes brushing them with a little olive oil and giving them a quick toast in the oven before loading them up.

Perfect Sides

These sandwiches are substantial enough that simple sides work best. A crisp green salad with bright vinaigrette cuts through all that richness, or some roasted potatoes tossed with rosemary and olive oil echo the comforting vibes. And do not forget something cold to drink, whether that is an Italian pilsner, a glass of red wine, or just sparkling water with plenty of lemon.

• Make extra beef because the leftovers somehow taste even better after the flavors have had more time to meld together
• Set up a toppings bar and let everyone build their own sandwich, which keeps the fun going and accommodates different heat preferences
• Keep plenty of napkins nearby because this is definitely a two hands, get messy kind of meal

Pin it

There is something deeply satisfying about a sandwich that requires two hands, plenty of napkins, and your full attention. Maybe that is why this recipe has become such a go to for feeding people I love.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What makes this sandwich Chicago-style?

The giardiniera—spicy pickled vegetables—and the au jus for dipping are hallmarks of Chicago-style Italian beef. The beef is slow-cooked until extremely tender, then piled high on Italian rolls.

→ Can I make this in a slow cooker?

Absolutely. Cook on low for 8 hours or high for 4-5 hours. The result will be equally tender and flavorful, perfect for set-it-and-forget-it convenience.

→ What cut of beef works best?

Chuck roast is ideal because it becomes fork-tender after long, slow cooking and has enough marbling to stay juicy. Brisket or round roast can work but may be less tender.

→ Is giardiniera necessary?

While traditional, you can substitute with pickled peppers or sliced banana peppers. However, giardiniera provides that authentic Chicago flavor profile with its mix of vegetables and spice.

→ How do I serve Italian beef sandwiches?

Pile the shredded beef high on rolls, spoon over extra au jus, and top with giardiniera. Serve additional au jus on the side for dipping—this is essential for the full experience.

→ Can these be made ahead?

Yes, actually they're better the next day. Make the beef ahead, refrigerate in the juices, then reheat gently before serving. The flavors develop even more over time.